
Smoked Eye of Round Roast Beef
6-8 Sandwiches
Can a cheap eye of round become tender, juicy smoked roast beef?
Eye of round is one of the leanest and most affordable cuts of beef, but its lack of marbling makes it challenging to cook without drying it out.
In this experiment, I tested whether an overnight dry brine, low-and-slow smoking, and a high-temperature reverse sear could transform this inexpensive cut into flavourful roast beef.
I smoked the roast on my Oklahoma Joe's Highland offset smoker at 225°F using hickory and cherry wood. Once the internal temperature reached 118–120°F, I removed the roast, allowed it to rest, and finished it with a high-temperature sear at approximately 475°F.
The finished roast beef was served in sandwiches with caramelized onions, horseradish mayo, and warm au jus.
The goal was to determine whether this cooking method could deliver tender, juicy roast beef from an affordable cut that is often considered too lean for smoking.
Ingredients
Smoked Eye of Round Roast Beef
- 1 eye of round beef roast
- Kosher salt, for overnight dry brining
- Black pepper, to taste
- Hickory wood splits
- Cherry wood splits
Preferred beef seasoning or BBQ rub
- Unreal Pepper Rub
- Mighty Mesquite
Caramelized Onions
- 2 large yellow onions, thinly sliced
- 2 tablespoons butter
- Salt, to taste
Horseradish Mayo
- ½ cup mayonnaise
- 2 tablespoons prepared horseradish
- 1 teaspoon lemon juice
- ¼ teaspoon black pepper
Au Jus
- 2 cups beef broth or stock
- Roast drippings, if available
- Salt and black pepper, to taste
Roast Beef Sandwiches
- Thinly sliced smoked eye of round roast beef
- 6–8 sandwich rolls or crusty bread
- Caramelized onions
- Horseradish mayo
- Warm au jus for dipping
Lumberjack Products Used
- Oklahoma Joe's Highland Offset Smoker
- Hickory Wood
- Cherry Wood
Directions
Prepare the Eye of Round Roast
Remove the eye of round from its packaging and pat it dry with paper towels.
Inspect the exterior and remove any thick surface fat and silver skin.
Silver skin is a tough connective tissue that does not break down during cooking. Removing it helps prevent chewy sections in the finished roast.
Avoid trimming away unnecessary meat during this process.
Dry Brine the Roast
Season the roast evenly with kosher salt on all sides.
Place the roast on a wire rack over a tray and refrigerate uncovered overnight.
The salt gradually penetrates the meat, improving seasoning throughout the roast.
Leaving the roast uncovered also helps dry the exterior surface, which promotes better crust development during the final sear.
Prepare the Oklahoma Joe's Highland Offset Smoker
Light the fire and bring the smoker to a stable cooking temperature of 225°F.
Use hickory as the primary smoking wood, with cherry added to complement the smoke profile.
Hickory provides a traditional, robust smoke flavour that works well with beef.
Cherry contributes a slightly sweeter smoke profile and can help develop a richer exterior colour.
Maintain proper airflow and a clean-burning fire throughout the cook.
Season the Eye of Round
Remove the roast from the refrigerator.
Apply black pepper and your preferred beef seasoning evenly over the exterior.
Because the roast was already dry-brined, avoid adding excessive additional salt.
Allow the seasoning to adhere to the surface before placing the roast on the smoker.
Smoke the Eye of Round
Place the seasoned roast on the Oklahoma Joe's Highland offset smoker.
Maintain the cooking temperature at approximately 225°F.
Insert a reliable meat thermometer into the thickest part of the roast.
Continue smoking until the internal temperature reaches approximately 118–120°F.
Eye of round contains very little intramuscular fat, making internal temperature control especially important.
Unlike cuts such as brisket or chuck roast, eye of round does not benefit from being cooked to high internal temperatures.
The objective is to develop smoke flavour while preserving the natural moisture of the beef.
Remove and Rest the Roast
Once the internal temperature reaches 118–120°F, remove the roast from the smoker.
Allow it to rest while preparing the smoker for the reverse sear.
Resting gives the internal temperature time to stabilize before exposing the exterior to high heat.
Monitor the temperature during this stage to account for carryover cooking.
Prepare for the Reverse Sear
Increase the cooking temperature to approximately 475°F.
The purpose of the reverse sear is to create a browned, flavourful exterior without exposing the roast to high heat throughout the entire cooking process.
A properly developed crust adds texture and enhances the overall beef flavour.
Reverse Sear the Eye of Round
Place the roast over the high-heat cooking area.
Sear the exterior, turning as needed to develop an even crust.
Avoid leaving the roast over direct heat for too long.
Monitor the internal temperature carefully during this stage.
For a medium-rare finish, target a final internal temperature of approximately 130–135°F, accounting for carryover cooking.
Remove the roast once the desired crust and internal temperature are achieved.
Prepare the Caramelized Onions
Peel and thinly slice the yellow onions.
Heat the butter in a skillet over medium-low heat.
Add the sliced onions and a pinch of salt.
Cook slowly, stirring occasionally, until the onions soften and develop a deep golden-brown colour.
Avoid cooking over excessively high heat, which can burn the onions before their natural sugars develop.
Properly caramelized onions add sweetness that balances the smoky beef and sharp horseradish mayo.
Prepare the Horseradish Mayo
Add the mayonnaise, prepared horseradish, lemon juice, and black pepper to a small bowl.
Mix thoroughly until the ingredients are fully combined.
Taste and adjust the horseradish according to your preferred level of heat.
Refrigerate until ready to assemble the sandwiches.
The horseradish provides a sharp, slightly spicy contrast to the richness of the smoked beef.
Prepare the Au Jus
Add the beef broth or stock to a saucepan.
Incorporate any available roast drippings for additional flavour.
Bring the mixture to a gentle simmer.
Taste and adjust the seasoning with salt and black pepper.
Keep warm until serving.
The au jus adds moisture and enhances the beef flavour, especially when using a naturally lean cut such as eye of round.
Rest and Slice the Roast Beef
Allow the roast to rest briefly after the final sear.
Place the roast on a cutting board.
Identify the direction of the muscle fibres and slice against the grain.
Cut the roast beef as thinly as possible.
Thin slicing is one of the most important steps when preparing eye of round.
Because the muscle fibres are relatively long and the cut contains little marbling, thick slices can feel chewy even when the roast is cooked correctly.
Slicing thinly against the grain shortens the muscle fibres and produces a more tender eating experience.
Assemble the Roast Beef Sandwiches
Slice the sandwich rolls or crusty bread.
Spread horseradish mayo over the bread.
Add the thinly sliced smoked eye of round roast beef.
Top with caramelized onions.
Close the sandwiches and serve immediately with warm au jus on the side.
Evaluate the Final Result
Evaluate the tenderness, moisture, smoke flavour, exterior crust, and overall texture of the roast beef.
- Pay particular attention to whether the combination of low-temperature smoking and a high-temperature reverse sear produced a tender result without drying out the lean meat.
- The objective of this experiment is to determine whether an inexpensive eye of round can deliver a satisfying smoked roast beef sandwich when prepared using the right cooking technique.