🍁SHIPS FREE on orders $49+ after discounts   🎄BLACK FRIDAY 20-30% OFF SITEWIDE🎄 

Two piles of golden-brown smoked chicken wings with visible seasoning and charred edges on a wooden cutting board. A glass bowl of additional wings sits behind them, flanked by Maritime Madness Garden Herb and Unreal Pepper Rub seasonings.
0 minute read   •  

By @yasmaniruizbello

Frozen vs Thawed Smoked Chicken Wings

Two piles of golden-brown smoked chicken wings with visible seasoning and charred edges on a wooden cutting board. A glass bowl of additional wings sits behind them, flanked by Maritime Madness Garden Herb and Unreal Pepper Rub seasonings.

Frozen vs Thawed Smoked Chicken Wings

@yasmaniruizbello

Servings

8-10

Cook Time

45 minutes

Do chicken wings really need to be thawed before they go on the smoker? In this cook, I divided one full pack of Costco chicken wings into two batches and cooked them side by side on my Traeger pellet grill. One batch went directly from the freezer to the smoker, while the other was fully thawed. Both batches received the same light coating of olive oil, Maritime Madness Unreal Pepper and Garden Herb seasonings, Lumberjack Char-Hickory and Cherry pellets, and cooking temperatures. The frozen wings received a 15-minute head start before the thawed wings went onto the smoker. Both batches were compared for cooking time, colour, taste, and skin texture.

Ingredients

  • 1 full pack Costco chicken wings, divided evenly
  • Olive oil, for a light coating
  • Maritime Madness Unreal Pepper
  • Maritime Madness Garden Herb seasoning

Lumberjack Products Used

  • Lumberjack Char-Hickory Pellets
  • Lumberjack Cherry Pellets

Directions

    1. Divide the Wings

    1. Divide one full pack of chicken wings evenly into two batches.
    2. Keep one batch completely frozen and fully thaw the second batch.

    2. Prepare the Pellet Grill

    1. Preheat the Traeger pellet grill to 375°F.
    2. Fill the hopper with a combination of Lumberjack Char-Hickory and Cherry pellets.
    3. The Char-Hickory pellets provide a bold smoke backbone, while the Cherry pellets add mild sweetness and help develop colour.

    3. Start the Frozen Wings

    1. Separate the frozen-solid wings and apply a light coating of olive oil to help the seasoning adhere.
    2. Place the frozen wings directly on the smoker at 375°F.
    3. Give the frozen batch a 15-minute head start before adding the thawed wings.

    4. Prepare the Thawed Wings

    1. Pat the thawed wings dry with paper towels to remove surface moisture.
    2. Apply a light coating of olive oil.
    3. Season the thawed wings evenly with Maritime Madness Unreal Pepper followed by Garden Herb seasoning.

    5. Season the Frozen Wings

    1. After the frozen wings have cooked for 15 minutes, check them and separate any pieces that were still stuck together.
    2. Season the frozen wings with Maritime Madness Unreal Pepper followed by Garden Herb seasoning.

    6. Add the Thawed Wings

    1. Place the thawed wings on the opposite side of the smoker.
    2. Leave space between the wings so heat and smoke can circulate evenly.
    3. Continue cooking both batches at 375°F under the same smoker conditions.

    7. Check the Wings

    1. Check both batches after the thawed wings have cooked for approximately 25 minutes.
    2. Use an INKBIRD thermometer to check several wings in the thickest part without touching bone.
    3. During the recorded cook, the frozen wings measured approximately 190°F. The thawed batch produced readings of approximately 149°F and 182°F, showing that some pieces cooked faster than others.

    8. Finish at High Heat

    1. Increase the pellet grill temperature to 425°F for the final 5 minutes.
    2. The higher finishing temperature helps render the fat and improve the skin texture.
    3. Perform a final temperature check in the thickest part of several wings. A final recorded reading was approximately 186°F.

    9. Remove and Rest the Wings

    1. Remove the wings from the smoker and place them briefly on a cooling rack before transferring them to a cutting board.
    2. Keep the wings unsauced during the comparison so the skin texture, seasoning, smoke flavour, colour, and taste can be judged fairly.
    3. Sauce may be added after the comparison.

    10. Compare the Results

    1. Compare the two batches for cooking time, colour, skin texture, taste, and overall preference.
    2. Both batches developed similar colour, although some pieces showed white spots and others developed more char.
    3. The frozen wings produced noticeably crispier skin.
    4. The thawed wings tasted good, but their skin was more rubbery than the frozen batch.
    5. The frozen wings were the overall winner. They required no thawing or advance preparation and went directly from the freezer to the Traeger.
    Sauce Bundle Banner
    BUILD A BUNDLE SAVE UP TO 20%

    Natural Ingredients
    No Artificial Additives

    Small-Batch
    Craftsmanship

    Free Shipping Across
    Canada